Missing 17-Year-Old Indiana Teen’s Body Found in Neighbor's Yard: Murder Charges Underway

Missing 17-Year-Old Valerie Tindall Indiana teen Neighbor's Yard murder case

By E.Baloyo , Parent Herald Dec 02, 10:24 am

In a tragic and alarming development that has shaken the community, the decomposed remains of the missing 17-year-old Indiana teen, Valerie Tindall, have been discovered buried in her neighbor's yard, leading to the initiation of murder charges against the neighbor.

Discovering the Missing 17-Year-Old

Valerie Tindall, who went missing nearly six months ago, was last seen heading to work for her neighbor, Patrick Scott, a 59-year-old resident of Arlington.

In a disturbing turn of events, the police unearthed Tindall's body on Tuesday inside a makeshift chest buried beneath debris on Scott's property, which is located less than a hundred yards from the teenager's home.

Scott, not just a neighbor but also Tindall's employer, allegedly confessed to detectives that he had strangled the teen with his belt, a chilling admission detailed in court documents.

The makeshift chest, constructed from wooden planks bought at Home Depot, served as the macabre resting place for Tindall's body, tightly sealed and buried in Scott's yard.

According to the court filings, Scott claimed that he had not planned to kill Tindall, asserting that it "just kind of happened." He alleged that the murder occurred after the teenager purportedly attempted to seduce and blackmail him into buying her a car.

Scott, who has a wife, daughter, and granddaughter, admitted to using his belt to strangle Tindall and then constructing the wooden box to conceal her body.

The grisly details emerged during the investigation, painting a harrowing picture of a crime that took place in close proximity to the victim's residence. The shocking admission and disturbing motive have sent shockwaves through the community.

Identifying the Victim and Legal Proceedings

On Thursday, the county coroner positively identified the remains recovered on Scott's property as those of Valerie Tindall.

Sheriff Allan Rice, in a press conference, emphasized that while this is not the desired outcome, the case is far from over, and justice will be sought. Scott now faces charges of murder and obstruction of justice.

Valerie Tindall, who worked for Scott's lawn mowing business, informed her parents on June 7 that she was heading to work. Scott was the last person to see her alive, according to court documents. The teenager's disappearance led to a missing person report when she failed to return home that day.

Timeline of an Ongoing Investigation

The investigation into Tindall's disappearance took a dark turn on October 11 when cadaver-sniffing dogs indicated the smell of decomposition near a pond on Scott's property. However, a search of the pond yielded no results. It was only on Tuesday, after the execution of a search warrant, that police discovered Tindall's body buried in Scott's yard.

The presence of orange-painted fingernails, matching the color Tindall was last seen wearing in a social media post on June 7, further confirmed her identity.

As the legal proceedings unfold, questions about Scott's motive and the circumstances leading to Tindall's tragic end linger. The cause of her death is pending the results of toxicology and a final autopsy report.

This chilling incident serves as a stark reminder of the unexpected dangers that can lurk behind seemingly familiar faces and neighborhoods. The community now grapples with the shock and grief of losing a young life in such a horrific manner, as the justice system moves forward with the murder charges against Patrick Scott.