Lawsuit Against Texas Claims Abortion Bans Violate Women's Rights to Health, Equality

lawsuit five Texas women abortion women’s rights Lawsuit against Texas for abortion Ban on abortion

By E.Baloyo , Parent Herald Mar 07, 09:20 pm

Photo: (Photo : Rick Kern / Getty Images)

Texas is facing a lawsuit from five women due to the state's stringent abortion laws, violating women's health and equality rights.

Five Texas women claimed that the lack of clarity regarding medical emergency exemptions in the state's abortion laws resulted in worsened medical conditions, putting their health, fertility, and lives at risk.

These five Texas women were left with only two options: wait for their health to decline further or seek care outside the state.

Lawsuit against Texas for abortion

As reported by CNN, the lawsuit filed by the five Texas women and two medical providers detailed their traumatic experiences of being denied abortion care during emergency complications in their wanted pregnancies.

The plaintiffs have shared harrowing stories of their struggles to find medical care and the heightened risks they faced due to the restrictions imposed by Texas' abortion laws.

Rather than seeking to block Texas' abortion bans completely, this lawsuit aims to clarify the conditions under which abortions can be performed in the state.

The plaintiffs asked the court to clarify that physicians may perform abortions when a good faith judgment is made that a physical emergent medical condition exists, posing a risk of death or significant harm to the pregnant individual, including fertility.

The plaintiffs contend that Texas' abortion bans violate the state constitution's provisions protecting fundamental rights and women's right to equality.

It also argued that these bans restrict access to abortion for people seeking medical care for conditions that endanger their lives or health. The plaintiffs seek to clarify these provisions to ensure that they are not denied the care they need in life-threatening situations.

The defendants in the lawsuit include Texas, its Attorney General Ken Paxton, the Texas Medical Board, and its Executive Director Stephen Brint Carlton.

In response to the lawsuit, Paxton's spokesperson stated he is committed to protecting families, mothers, and unborn children.

Violating women's rights to health and equality

According to the Washington Post, the abortion ban in Texas forced four women, namely Lauren Hall, Lauren Miller, Anna Zargarian, and Ashley Brandt, to travel to other states to obtain emergency abortions.

Although Amanda Zurawski, the primary plaintiff in the case, knew her fetus had no chance of survival, she could not have an abortion and was only permitted to give birth after undergoing septic shock, which left her with permanent physical harm.

During Zurawski's sixth month of pregnancy, her doctor informed her that she had cervical insufficiency and that her fetus would eventually die.

She inquired about her options, but her healthcare team informed her that Texas' anti-abortion law prevented them from doing anything.

Until her fetus no longer had a detectable heartbeat or she became critically ill, Zurawski's doctors could not intervene.

As a result, she was compelled to wait for her health to deteriorate and potentially suffer. Zurawski soon developed sepsis, a life-threatening blood infection, and her family flew to her bedside, fearing for her life.

According to Slate, as her health status worsened, doctors could finally induce delivery without violating Texas' abortion law.

However, if she had received an abortion, it would have avoided the unnecessary harm and suffering that she experienced, not only the psychological trauma that came with three days of waiting but also the physical damage her body suffered, the extent of which is still being assessed.