Father of Female High School Skier Claims Transgender Competition Unfair to Girls

By Lucia Paula , Parent Herald May 30, 10:10 pm

Photo: (Photo : JASON CONNOLLY/AFP via Getty Images)

In a recent California-Nevada high school girls' skiing championship, a transgender female athlete emerged as the state champion, leading to the father of another participant voicing his concerns about what he perceives as an unfair competition for girls. June Watterson, a sophomore, secured the girls' state title on March 6 with a remarkable 17-second lead. While she competes against girls in skiing, she still participates in the boys' category for biking.

Transgender Female Emerges as Champion in California-Nevada High School Girls' Skiing Championship

The concerned father, who chose to remain anonymous to avoid potential backlash against him and his daughter, argues that the skiing competition becomes unfair when transgender athletes are allowed to compete. He spoke to the Daily Mail, stating, "Hormones and drugs are just introducing drugs into sport. It's not fair on the girls. I'm all about being inclusive and accepting people, but they have men racing in women's sports."

He firmly believes that individuals who have gone through male puberty or are currently experiencing it should only compete against others who have had similar experiences. He acknowledges the importance of inclusivity but expresses concerns about potential advantages conferred by male puberty, which could affect the fairness of the competition.

Critics of transgender participation in sports argue that allowing transgender females, who were assigned male at birth, to compete against cisgender females may create an unequal playing field due to potential physiological advantages gained during male puberty. This issue has sparked ongoing debates worldwide, with varying perspectives on the topic.

According to FOX News, the father emphasized that he does not hold the winning athlete responsible for the situation. Instead, he directs his frustration towards the competition organizers and higher authorities, stating, "These kids are kids, [and] they live in the world adults have created. I don't blame the winning athlete. This is a failure at the administrative level and higher." He firmly believes that allowing males to compete in women's sports jeopardizes the integrity of women's athletics.

Concerned Father Voices Concerns Over Fairness in Girls' Sports Amid Transgender Participation Debate

The debate surrounding transgender participation in sports extends beyond this particular incident. Advocates emphasize the importance of inclusivity and equal opportunities for transgender athletes, highlighting the need to support their rights and identities. Conversely, critics argue for fair competition, advocating for sports divisions based on the biological sex assigned at birth.

It is crucial to consider diverse perspectives and engage in constructive dialogue when addressing the issue of transgender participation in high school sports. Balancing inclusivity and maintaining a level playing field is a complex task that requires careful consideration and the development of comprehensive policies.

According to Bolly Inside, the incident involving the high school girls' skiing championship highlights the ongoing debate on fairness and competition in sports. The concerned father's statement sheds light on the concerns of some individuals who believe that transgender participation may impact the integrity of women's athletics. As this conversation continues, it is essential to find a balanced approach that respects the rights of transgender individuals while ensuring fair and equitable competition for all athletes.