President Donald Trump's decision to bring back the Presidential Fitness Test has sparked intense debate among parents nationwide.
The test, which was phased out in 2013 during former President Barack Obama's administration, will once again require students to perform physical challenges, including the mile run, sit-ups, push-ups, and flexibility tests. Many parents remember their own experiences with the test and express serious concerns about its impact on their children's mental health and self-esteem.
The announcement came in July 2025 when Trump signed an executive order surrounded by professional athletes in the White House Roosevelt Room. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. will oversee the program as part of the broader "Make America Healthy Again" initiative. The order states that declining physical fitness poses "a threat to the vitality and longevity of our country" and weakens America's economy, military readiness, and national morale, according to Cronkite News.
Concerns Among Parents
Parents across the country are sharing their own childhood experiences with the test, and many memories are far from positive. "I remember how hurtful this program was when we were in school. Traumatic and bullying. Hopeless," wrote Mike from Salem, New Hampshire, in response to media polls about the test's return. Similar sentiments are echoing through social media platforms and parent groups nationwide.
The original Presidential Fitness Test, which ran from 1966 to 2013, required students to meet specific benchmarks to earn awards. For example, a 14-year-old girl needed to run a mile in under eight minutes, complete 40 sit-and-reaches, shuttle-run in about 10 seconds, and do 47 curl-ups to qualify for recognition, among other things, 29News reported.
Physical education expert Judy LoBianco, who worked in New Jersey schools for over two decades, believes the test can embarrass less athletic kids, make them anxious, and discourage them from pursuing fitness. She argues that modern physical education should focus on joy, social interaction, and life skills rather than competitive testing.
Implementation Questions Remain
Parents are also questioning the practical aspects of the revived program, as many wonder whether schools with lower-performing students will receive additional resources, better meals, and improved physical education equipment.
The Trump administration has positioned the test as part of a broader focus on youth health, citing concerning statistics about childhood obesity and physical inactivity. Kennedy's "Make America Healthy Again" report highlights that more than 70% of children ages six to 17 fail to meet federal guidelines for daily physical activity, as per NPR.
